Federal Court Orders Woman to Unlock iPhone With Her Finger

The Frey Law Firm, LLC Team

Fresh off the controversy surrounding the FBI and the DOJ’s legal battle over the iPhone at the center of the San Bernardino investigation, a federal judge has authorized a warrant that reportedly orders a woman to unlock her iPhone with her fingerprint. The identity theft suspect in the case is required, per the warrant, to comply with the request. According to media reports, it remains unclear why the authorities are interested in the content of the phone. With the continued advances in encryption and security, it is expected that litigation over these issues will continue to evolve, as well as the case law associated therewith.

Smartphones & the 4th Amendment

It is often said that a “man’s house is his castle” and the 4th Amendment is explicit in protecting the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches. Today, there may be no “effect” more sacrosanct than a person’s smartphone or iPhone. A person’s phone can contain the most private and intimate details of a person’s life:

  • family photos
  • geolocation data
  • financial information
  • hobbies, interests
  • religious beliefs
  • political perspectives
  • friends
  • communications
  • health
  • business documentation …… and the list goes on and on.

Today, a Forensic Examination of a Person’s Phone May Be Considered More Intrusive Than a Thorough Search of Person’s Home.

Expect continued litigation and debate. The battle between the right to be secure in their effects against unreasonable searches, the right to remain silent and the right to not be compelled to incriminate oneself will continually the ability of the government to investigate criminal activity intensifies. The principals that have guided 4th Amendment jurisprudence for centuries can be applied to the ever-changing landscape of digital technology and encryption. However, there will be “hard cases” and “hard cases make bad law.” For instance, precedent set from a decision involving a terror suspect can, and most certainly would, be applied in other, relatively less serious and controversial cases, as well as in other ways that are simply not foreseeable. Whether it is an order to provide access to a phone via a fingerprint, a pass code, or a retina scan, the implications are serious for the government, the individual suspect and society as a whole.

Client Reviews

Ron was reliably reachable and knowledgeable about the intricacies of the legal ramifications in my case. This was a criminal defense case for possession of child...

Posted by John

Mr. Frey started work on my son’s suspension case immediately after contacting him. He quickly made me aware of the various documents I needed to gather in support of the...

Posted by Michael

I can’t imagine a better experience working with Ron. He is informed, persistent, and incredibly responsive. I required his assistance in getting two convictions...

Posted by Criminal Defense Client

I hired Ron to represent my son who was charged with a serious federal crime. Due to the nature and seriousness of the charge, I needed absolute confidence in my son’s...

Posted by Federal Crime Client

Mr. Frey is an excellent attorney! Not only is he extremely knowledgable, Mr. Frey was very responsive and attentive to all of my questions and explained everything so...

Posted on Avvo.com

Ron Frey is not just an attorney, but he became an integral extension of our family this past year. As we prayerfully searched for an attorney, on a Sunday afternoon, he...

Posted on Avvo.com

I hired Ron back in April of 2016 as I had two felony charges hanging over my head. I called him around 5 pm and he called me back around 5:30 pm and we met in person the...

Posted by a client

My case was unique, and difficult. It was from 36 years ago, when I was 22 years of age. I had just moved to Cleveland, Ohio and I unfortunately found myself in the wrong...

Posted on Avvo.com

I did not know what to look for in a defense attorney, but based on the first two meetings, Mr. Frey was honest in his communication, and very direct about the process...

Posted by Criminal Defense Client

Mr. Frey promptly started work on my case after my initial contact on the phone (August 2009). He was thoroughly prepared and professional throughout my entire case at...

Posted by a client

Attorney Ron Frey is great, very informative and he certainly knows his stuff. I called to ask for advice and he made me realize that I needed a lawyer for sure. He...

Posted on Avvo.com

I hired Ron a year ago and he immediately worked so hard on my case. He showed compassion and understood that my “offense” was nothing but misunderstanding gone horribly...

Posted by previous client

Ron helped my son a couple times and I am extremely happy at how Ron moved forward with the cases and kept us informed all the way throughout the process. If my son or...

Posted by Ralph

Ronald Frey is an excellent lawyer and I would highly recommend him to someone in need of his skills. In his specialty area, Ron knows the law completely, and has the...

Posted on Avvo.com

Mr. Frey did an amazing job! I couldn’t have asked for a better attorney. At one of the lowest points in my life, Ron was there for me. He did such a terrific job. I...

Posted by a client

Mr. Frey’s intelligence and expertise proved to provide me with the best legal representation. Without his guidance and defense, I would not have an successful outcome…

Posted on Avvo.com

Get in Touch

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 We Fight for You!
Fill out the contact form or call us at (844) 766-3739 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message