What if the Government Fails to Preserve, or Destroys, Digital Evidence During an Investigation?

Given the proliferation of data storage devices, ranging from computers and cell phones, to Fitbits and gaming systems, it should come as no surprise that criminal investigators often focus on securing digital evidence from these devices. Law enforcement utilizes a variety of methods to secure digital evidence, including extracting data, or making a forensic copy of the data from a device. When evaluating the integrity and thoroughness of the investigation, it is important for the defense attorney to consider not only what digital evidence was secured, but also any digital evidence that may have been left uncollected or unpreserved.
Due Process
The United States Supreme Court has ruled that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution protects an accused from being convicted of a crime when the government fails to preserve materially exculpatory evidence or destroys, in bad faith, potentially useful evidence. California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479, 489, 104 S.Ct. 2528, 81 L.Ed.2d 413 (1984); Arizona v. Youngblood, 488 U.S. 51, 58, 109 S.Ct. 333, 102 L.Ed.2d 281 (1988). Evidence is constitutionally material when it possesses “an exculpatory value that was apparent before the evidence was destroyed, and [is] of such a nature that the defendant would be unable to obtain comparable evidence by other reasonably available means.” Trombetta, 467 U.S., at 489.
Failing to Preserve Digital Evidence
Whenever law enforcement fails to preserve digital evidence in a case, an inquiry should be made in order to determine whether the failure constituted a due process violation. When it comes to data storage devices, it is often the case that law enforcement’s failure to properly preserve the evidence will prevent a defendant or suspect from being able to conduct an independent forensic examination to prepare for trial and present a defense. Further, if the unpreserved evidence was potentially useful, a hearing should be held to determine whether law enforcement exhibited bad faith in failing to protect and preserve the data, or a complete forensic copy of the same.
Motion to Preserve
If you have case involving digital evidence, or evidence from the Internet or an online source, it is important to determine whether the evidence was properly secured and preserved. Further, it may be appropriate for counsel to file a motion to preserve certain evidence to bolster the argument in the event evidence is destroyed, misplaced or corrupted. Attorney Ron Frey and The Frey Law Firm have a great deal of experience representing individuals, companies and organizations in criminal investigations that involve digital evidence and Internet related crimes.
If you have a question pertaining to an issue involving digital evidence or a computer crime, please call The Frey Law Firm for a free initial consultation.
Questions About Lost or Destroyed Digital Evidence
What happens if the government loses or destroys digital evidence in my case?
Lost or destroyed digital evidence can matter in a criminal case, but it does not automatically require a particular result. A lawyer may look at what was lost, whether comparable records still exist, and how the data was handled. The significance of a gap in the evidence depends on the facts of the case and the law that applies.
Does it matter if police deleted video or failed to save phone data?
Yes, it can matter. Video, phone extracts and other digital files may be important, and a failure to preserve them should be examined. Whether that failure supports a challenge depends on what the evidence appeared to show, whether other sources remain, and the circumstances of the loss. Those issues are fact-specific and should be reviewed under current law.
Can a lawyer ask that phone data or other digital evidence be preserved?
Yes. Counsel can often ask a court to order that certain digital evidence be preserved so it is not later deleted, misplaced or corrupted. Timing can matter, because some systems overwrite or discard data on a schedule. Attorney Ron Frey of The Frey Law Firm, LLC offers a Free Initial Confidential Consultation at (844) 766-3739 to discuss whether the firm can assist.





